Understanding Refinance Application Denials

October 17, 2023

When you're seeking answers as to why your refinance application was denied, your lender is obligated to provide specific reasons. They must furnish an "adverse action" notice explaining the loan rejection. Refinancing essentially means obtaining a new loan to pay off your existing mortgage, necessitating a requalification process. Each lender you approach will scrutinize your income, credit, debt, and property value to assess your financial situation. If your financial circumstances have changed since your home purchase, your refinance could be denied.

What to Do if Your Mortgage Refinance is Denied:

  • If your mortgage refinance application is rejected, it's important to remain positive

  • A denial from one lender doesn't imply that every lender will reject your application

  • Request the precise reasons for the denial; the lender is obligated to provide these reasons in writing

Common Reasons for Refinance Denials:

  • Excessive Debt: One of the most prevalent reasons for refinance denials is an excessively high level of debt. Lenders impose limits on the debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, which compares your monthly income to your monthly debt payments.

  • Poor Credit: A low credit score can be a significant impediment to refinancing. Conventional mortgages often require a minimum credit score of 620, and recent credit issues can further complicate your chances.

  • Declining Home Value: Lenders want to ensure that the property's value justifies the refinance. If the property's value doesn't meet the lender's criteria, your loan may be denied. Lenders use your home as collateral, which means that if you fail to repay your loan, the lender can take possession of the property through foreclosure. A significant drop in your home's value since your initial mortgage can lead to being "underwater" on your mortgage.

  • Incomplete Application: Surprisingly, incomplete applications are a common reason for refinance denials. It's crucial to provide all the documents and data requested by your lender and ensure your application is complete.

  • Unverifiable Information: Lenders may encounter difficulties in verifying certain details in your mortgage application, such as your employment history.

  • Insufficient Cash: Refinancing often involves bringing cash to cover closing costs and fees for the new loan. In some cases, lenders may allow you to roll these costs into your loan or provide a credit in exchange for a higher interest rate. However, "insufficient cash" is a frequent reason for refinance denials.

Improving Your Chances After a Refinance Denial:

  • Check Your Credit Report for Errors: If the refinance denial is due to credit history, ensure the accuracy of your credit report. You can obtain a free copy of your credit report from major reporting agencies and dispute any inaccuracies.

  • Enhance Your Credit: Elevate your credit score by consistently paying bills on time, reducing credit card balances, and avoiding unnecessary loans.

  • Reduce Debt: Pay down outstanding debts to lower your debt-to-income ratio, potentially improving your credit score.

  • Specialized Refinance Programs: If your home's value is a persistent issue, explore specialized programs offered by non-qualified mortgage (non-QM) lenders. These programs may feature shorter waiting periods or alternative income verification methods.

In summary, a refinance denial isn't the end of the road. Understanding the reasons for the denial and taking steps to address them can lead to future success in your refinancing endeavors.